I was a little torn about what to do with the bench at first. After all it's pretty much just a flat board. I've seen people on Trading Spaces put batting and fabric on a wood board a bunch of times for a padded bench, it didn't look too hard. All you need is fabric and a staple gun right? Well, in the end I wasn't so sure and I didn't want to ruin the bench and then have to buy a whole new one. Jared and I unscrewed the lid from the bench and took it to a professional reupholstering shop in Orland. It ended up being about 60 bucks (fabric included) which I thought was a little expensive, but not ridiculous. Actually, I'm going to be honest with you here, I have no idea if that's a good deal or not. Turns out there aren't that many reupholstering shops in the area and I didn't want to drag the bench lid around for quotes. So if you think we got ripped off, please leave a comment. :D
Two weeks go by and I drive back to pick up the lid. I wanted to have it all put back together on the bench by the time Jared got home from work to surprise him. The lid was screwed to the bench in 3 places, 2 hinges and a stop bar to keep the lid from opening more than 90 degrees. I put the lid on the bench and the stop bar is on the opposite side of the lid from where it originally was and the hinges are too close together and wouldn't line up. Oh. . .I was pretty ticked. Mainly because we paid good money so it wouldn't get messed up, and two because I didn't want to make 2 extra trips out to Orland to drop and pick it up again.
Long story short my mother was nice enough to come to the house on a Thursday when the shop came to pick up the lid and the bench (the only day they would do it), and it was ready 2 days later. . . but we had to go pick it up.
Apparently the new hole in the bench for the stop bar had to be on the opposite side because they couldn't screw it back into the old one after it was reupholstered. They said the hole was too big. I guess they thought that was ok to put it on the opposite side? They never called to ask. They also never explained why the hinges got messed up, I guess because they are dumb. Who knows. When they took the bench back to fix it I told them I didn't want any holes showing, and as few new holes screwed into the bench as possible. In the end they came through, and the upholstering job is great. What a pain though! Here is the finished product.



